Judge acquits Peraire-Bueno brothers in $25 million Ethereum MEV case

A federal judge in New York acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of charges related to an operation in which prosecutors alleged they obtained approximately $25 million in cryptocurrency.

U.S. District Judge for the Southern District of New York Jessica G. L. Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering charges. The case involved an Ethereum MEV operation in which the original indictment alleged they obtained approximately $25 million in cryptocurrency.

The decision followed a deadlocked jury and a mistrial declaration in November 2025. It represents a significant setback for the first U.S. federal criminal case focused on this form of Ethereum MEV exploit.

Ethereum MEV and the requirement to prove deception

The court concluded that prosecutors had not proven a material false statement required for the wire fraud theory in this case.

According to Bloomberg Law, CoinDesk, and BleepingComputer, the judge acquitted the brothers. The full reasoning and all wording attributed to the judge could not be independently verified from the publicly available primary court document.

Indictment described a 2023 operation

The original indictment from May 2024 alleged that the brothers obtained approximately $25 million in cryptocurrency in about 12 seconds during a 2023 operation.

The case involved manipulating the ordering of on-chain transactions and the alleged exploitation of a deficiency in relay software within the Ethereum MEV environment. These claims were part of the indictment, not a judicial finding of guilt.

Following the acquittal, it is therefore inaccurate to use labels such as “theft” or “heist” as statements of an established fact.

Decision does not legalize all MEV practices

The decision concerns the specific charges and evidence in this case. It is not a general confirmation of the legality of MEV practices or similar exploits.

The ruling’s significance lies in the narrower application of a specific wire fraud theory to transactions in a permissionless environment. However, it does not necessarily rule out other criminal or civil claims.

It remains to be seen whether the Department of Justice will issue a statement on the ruling or next steps, whether the full decision will appear in the official court docket, and how prosecutors will adjust their legal theories in future cases involving MEV, validators, and blockchain relay services.

Sources

  • Bloomberg Law – Independently confirms the acquittal on November 16, 2026, and the court’s finding that the brothers did not lie as part of the charged scheme.
  • CoinDesk – Reports on the acquittal, its connection to the 2025 mistrial, and that the court closed the case.
  • U.S. Department of Justice – Documents the original charges from May 2024 and prosecutors’ claims of approximately $25 million and a 12-second operation; it is not proof of guilt.
  • BleepingComputer – Corroborates that the court issued an acquittal due to insufficient evidence of a material false statement.

Verified and updated: November 18, 2026 15:23

Sharing